Two days ago I wrote that the BKX (the banking index) might be topping out around these levels ($105-$106). I would like today to put some more substance to this trade by actually going long the S5PROP (S&P500 property and casualty insurers) @ $287.25 vs. shorting the BKX @ $104.65, as a pair trade. Not saying that S5PROP won't go down, just saying that BKX would go down
further if that was the case. Why? First, I think that, following this year's record -number-of-hurricanes season, the insurers are entering what I deem to be a cyclical bull market in terms of premium power, whereas the banks might just be coming out of one, if my "not-so-rosy" scenario for the U.S. economy materializes in the second half of 2006.
Second, insurers tend to do better in a rising interest rate environment -- so, if Helicopter Ben goes nuts with the i-rate lever (and the current strength in the U.S. economy seems to indicate that the Fed indeed won't stop raising rates until we see the 4.75% level at least), that would also be better for the insurers than the banks. Third, if the yield curve inverts (
as I discussed yesterday), the banks would then be even more hard-pressed to reproduce their stellar performances and record profits of this past year. And yes, I come from the old school of thought which advocates that banks are way too accustomed to making "the easy money". Sorry to rain on someone's parade, but the easy money is already made, mates! Going forward, making money is going to require much smarter risk-taking (with possibly lower leverage or else we would be really asking for trouble!). Except for Goldman (which, let's face it, is actually a hedge fund with an M&A advisory department), I am struggling to name an investment bank which really knows what they are doing in that department. The bottom line is the end result of all this
has to be higher volatility in the market, which isn't so good for the banking brethren either.
Maybe this trade is way too obvious and thus, by definition, will fail. Maybe... I have a feeling though that we won't be seeing VIX at 11 for too long. Buy 18-month SPX vol. The storm is coming.